British vs. U.S elections

I had a political science professor in college, and this was the mid-1970s, that had very specific views.  Sometimes I agreed with him, sometimes I did not.  What he always succeeded in doing was forcing one to challenge long-held views.

One assertion he often made was comparing how the United States elects a president to how the United Kingdom elects a prime minister through their parliamentary system.  It is well understood that our systems of democracy are quite different, but he always argued the Brits do it better than us.

The length of a presidential campaign in America is long, very long.  Sometimes the positioning of candidates for president of the United States begins when the last election ends.  There are straw polls, all kinds of gatherings, the endless primary elections, then the political parties have their conventions, nominating their respective presidential candidates.  Labor Day normally denotes the start of the presidential campaign.

How is it done in Britain?  There is a deadline for an election to be held, but normally the prime minister calls the election before that date.  The UK parliamentary election campaign has  begun in 2024.  It will last for 5 weeks, with the election to be held July 4.  I find it interesting that the balloting will happen on a day not necessarily a date to remember in Britain, July 4th, the day commemorating the American Declaration of Independence from King George.

My professor always thought a brief, lively election campaign of 5 weeks in Britain is much better than the long, drawn-out campaigns for American president.

My former professor may have a point.

3 thoughts on “British vs. U.S elections

  1. The UK is a tugboat compared to the US in size and the number of jurisdictions. 4 compared to the 50 states plus territories plus other extraneous jurisdictions (like the military spread throughout the world). The UK’s first past the post system also kind of rigs it for the right which is mostly just the Tories whereas the left is much more splintered. That’s changing though. Question? How would it be in either country if the Irish system were used? Longer for sure in the UK but perhaps more accurate, more fair.

    1. I agree the British system has its drawbacks, just saying the length of our presidential campaigns have become so long I thought back to my professor’s argument in the mid 70s. Thanks for the comment.

  2. Unworkable. We have state that start voting 46 days before elections. Or about 6 weeks. In the minds of many, voters would be disenfranchised.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.