data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0f6bd/0f6bdddbac3e305d7be31c0cdd1b5683b7d327bc" alt=""
I was having a conversation the other day about the serious crime problems in the east side of Indianapolis. My mind went back to the 1960s when my aunt and uncle built their first home in that area.
The eastside was economically thriving at that time. There were Ford and Chrysler auto plants. Western Electric manufactured telephones for AT&T. There were lots of smaller companies around supporting and supplying those operations, along with many small businesses in general.
But the Indianapolis east side is not what it once was. Chrysler, Ford and Western Electric closed years ago. Many of the small businesses have also left the area. That has led to poverty and crime.
Changing economics brings changes and sometimes those changes are tragic. The Indianapolis east side is one example.
Something is happening at the national level that not only impacts jobs and the economy, but our democracy as well. To state it bluntly, local news is economically dying in the United States of America.
There has been a lot of hand-wringing and talk about what to do about local news sources just going away. But there is a possible solution that may surprise you.
Steve Waldman is president of Report for America, which places journalists into local newsrooms and also chairs the Rebuild Local News Coalition. He makes a compelling argument that any infrastructure legislation should include provisions strengthening sources of local news.
I know many have argued that proposals within the infrastructure plans being considered on Capitol Hill already do not meet what many consider genuine infrastructure. I am not here to take a side on that debate, but I would ask you consider the arguments Mr. Waldman presents.
He says local news is part of our democratic civic infrastructure and that infrastructure is crumbling economically. Here is one number that must be considered – there are 60% fewer local news reporters today compared to the year 2000.
That means a newsroom staffed with 100 reporters in 2000 now employs about 40 journalists. That also assumes the newsroom is still in business today.
Senator Maria Cantwell is from the state of Washington, and as chair of the Commerce Committee, she has proposed spending $2.4 billion on news infrastructure.
I know many journalists will say, whoa, having the government subsidize news could be a slippery slope. Could the news media remain independent in this scenario?
News organizations have, in fact, been subsidized in the past. One example is a better postal rate for news. News operations are also entitled to all sorts of tax breaks available to other businesses.
One idea that is being explored would allow every American to buy $250 worth of news subscriptions and provide a refundable tax credit to pay for it. This would be available to all taxpayers, not just those itemizing their deductions.
I do not pretend to have all the answers, but I know the local news business is in serious trouble, with news deserts growing throughout the nation. Something needs to be done.
I do try and play a small part with this news blog. Here in the northern suburbs of Indianapolis, we have many sources of news. There is the Indianapolis Star, Indianapolis Business Journal, Hamilton County Reporter, Noblesville Times along with local television and radio news operations. Special kudos to public radio station WFYI, which has been growing its staff of journalists in recent years.
Studies have consistently shown that a lack of local news systems eventually lead to more corruption, lower voter turnout, added polarization and more alienation within the local community. Also consider this – the vacuum created by the disintegration of local news is now being filled by toxic disinformation, conspiracy theories and polarizing national content.
Again, I do not pretend to have all the answers, but we need to look for serious solutions to the lack of local news sources. After all, I’ll be 70 years old in the coming months. I tried to quit this news blog once and COVID brought me back. We need more than volunteers such as myself to bring you local news.
Read Steve Waldman’s full commentary at this link.